next previous
Up: Home Page

Studying the Fueling and Unification Models for the Seyfert Galaxy
NGC3227 Using Adaptive Optics Imaging and Spectroscopy


Scott C. Chapman

University of British Columbia, Vancouver, B.C. V6T 1Z4,  Canada
Electronic-mail:schapman@astro.ubc.ca

and

Simon Morris


Dominion Astrophysics Observatory, Victoria, B.C.,  Canada
Electronic-mail: simon@dao.nrc.ca



Abstract:

We present high spatial resolution, near-IR images in J,H, and K of the nucleus of NGC 3227, obtained with the Adaptive Optics bonnette on CFHT. The $\sim0.15''$ (17pc) resolution allows us to probe structures in the very core region at unprecedented scales. We are able to identify an inwards spiraling starburst in all three near-IR bands and a counterpart in an HST V-band image. Dust obscuration becomes significantly less pronounced at longer wavelengths, revealing the true geometry of the core region. The observed structures may help to ellucidate how the material needed to fuel the active nucleus is traveling from the orbit just inside the Inner Linblad Resonance (ILR) to the smaller 50pc scale probed by our images, and further down to where viscous forces may take over to carry material to the accretion disk of the central black hole. Additional support for this scenerio is obtained from OASIS Integral Field Spectroscopy with 0.8'' resolution.

Introduction

  It is generally accepted that pronounced activity in galaxies hosting Active Galactic Nuclei (AGN) results from accretion onto a supermassive black hole. This paradigm has led to a plethora of research into AGN, of which the problems of overcoming the angular momentum barrier to fuel the nucleus and unification of the AGN types have risen to the forefront as especially vexing and controversial. Near-IR imaging has proven to be a powerful means to study these AGN problems since the dust extinction is reduced, and the wavelength range lies between two domains carrying complementary pieces of information - the visible (excited gas in the NLR), and the thermal IR-radio range (cool dust and synchrotron emission from electrons). A fresh perspective can be gained on the core regions of AGNs through the high resolution images now possible thanks to adaptive optics (AO). Here, we present observations of NGC 3227 obtained with Pueo, the AO system recently commissioned on the 3.6 m Canada-France-Hawaii Telescope. NGC 3227 is an SABa galaxy, interacting with its dwarf elliptical neighbor, NGC 3226. It has been much studied in recent years as it contains many of the elements thought to be related to the formation and evolution of active nuclei: emission line regions excited by both starburst and AGN continuum, strong interaction, and a stellar bar (Gonzales Delgado & Perez 1997, Arribas & Mediavilla 1994).

Observations

  The images were obtained at the CFHT in March, 1997, using the MONICA near-IR camera (Nadeau et al. 1994) mounted at the f/20 focus of the Adaptive Optics Bonnette (AOB). The detector is a Rockwell NICMOS3 array with 256x256 pixels and a 0.034''/pix scale. The CFHT AOB is based on curvature wavefront sensing (Roddier 1991), and uses a 19 zone bimorph mirror to correct the wavefront distortions. As the field size is small (9''x9''), blank sky images were taken intermitantly between science frames. On-source images were taken in a mosaic of 4 positions, alternately putting the galaxy core in each of the four quadrants of the array. Flux and PSF calibrations were performed using the UKIRT standard stars fs13 and fs25. Flat-field images were taken on the dome with the lamps turned on and off to account for the thermal glow of the telescope. The nucleus of the galaxy itself was used as the guiding source for the AO system, roughly a 14th magnitude point source. The natural seeing averaged 0.6''-0.8'' throughout the observations resulting in relatively high strehl ratios in all bands, and FWHM of 0.14'', 0.17'', 0.22'' at K, H, J bands respectively. At a distance of 15Mpc for NGC3227, 1''=76pc using H0=50.

The OASIS instrument allows spatially resolved spectroscopy to be obtained at the resolution provided by the adaptive optics bonnette. Spectral imagery was obtained in the $H_\alpha$ and [SIII] lines under fairly poor seeing conditions and only part of the data obtained is usable since guiding was lost intermitantly in some of the exposures. The best corrected FWHM obtained is only 0.8'' using the 0.3''/pixel sampling. The [SIII] lines are excited under similar conditions to the [OIII] line and is typically 1/3 the peak intensity. The advantage for adaptive optics is that the PSF correction is much better at 9000Angstroms (SIII) than 5000 (OIII).

Results

The CFHT K- and HST V-band images are presented in Figure 1(a,b) on a magnitude (log) scale, chosen because AO provides a high dynamic range (typically 1.3$\times$104 at K) and significant details are seen at all flux levels. A diffuse, ellongated structure containing wispy spiral bands is seen surrounding the nucleus in all wavelengths. Subtraction of a smooth model reveals that this region is punctuated with bright knotty structures tracing out a mini-spiral pattern within a region 3''x2'' (Figure 2(c,d)). We explored several methods of removing the low frequency galactic component, including various smoothing filters, a one-dimentional elliptical isophote model, and a multi-component (bulge+disk+point source) elliptical isophote model. All methods consistently unveil the knotty spiral structure. However, the core region of the galaxy has large departures from ellipticity and subtracting isophotal fitting models results in prominent artifacts which obscure structural details over much of the region of interest.


 
Figure 1: NGC3227 (TOP ROW) CFHT K and HST F606W (V-band) images. (BOTTOM ROW) close up of same two images with smooth model subtracted
\begin{figure}
\centerline{
\psfig {figure=chapman_fig1.ps,height=6in,angle=0}
}\end{figure}

We form color maps by convolving the images to the worst resolution of a given pair and taking the flux ratio (Figure 2(a,b)). Any color gradients in these images can result from several different processes: 1) change in dust 2) change in stellar population 3) change in gas. The most prominent feature is an irregular-shaped patch to the southwest. The fact that this region appears clearly as a deficit in the V-band image, and takes on a patchy morphology is strong evidence for dust obscuration as the source of the color gradient. The region is therefore most pronounced the V-K color map (figure 2a), since the K image is least affected by dust. The J-K image indicates that substantial dust still affects this region in the J-band. The color maps reveal that the nucleus is very red, possibly as a result of thermal dust emission in the K band. The red colors of the spiral starburst knots stand out from a region slightly bluer than the larger scale bulge of the galaxy.

 
Figure 2: NGC3227 (TOP ROW) K-V map; K-J map (BOTTOM ROW) K-band ellipse fit profile; 18cm MERLIN image
\begin{figure}
\centerline{
\psfig {figure=chapman_fig2.ps,height=6in,angle=0}
} \end{figure}

The 1D profiles of the galaxies are similar at V, J, H and K (figure 2c shows K profile), displaying a bump in ellipticity between 1 and 2 arcseconds radius, while the PA twists by $\sim 8$ degrees. This is coincident in radius and position angle (PA) with the elongated region defined by the nuclear spiral. There is also a sharp rise and fall in ellipticity within the central 0.5 arcsecond radius, but here the PA twists significantly ($\gt 20\%$). The feature is most clearly visible in the J-K and V-K color maps, as it seems to be bluer than the rest of the galaxy at K. The HST V-band profile is distorted at the smallest scales as the image is saturated within 0.2" radius and dominated by diffraction spikes, thus identification of the feature is more difficult at this wavelength. This feature may represent the warping of a gaseous disk, with the presence of a starbursting component as it is coincident with the innermost ring of knot structures seen in the model subtracted images. Such a warped nuclear disk is thought to be rather common in active galaxies and related to their central activity (Schreier et al. 1998). The twisted isophotes make the interpretation of the elongated feature as a nuclear bar potential somewhat dubious, but the profiles are difficult to analyze with certainty as the feature is near the level of our image resolution. Higher resolution images might reveal the twist as even smaller-scale nested bars.

The images are also compared to the 6cm and 18cm MERLIN radio continuum emission, both of which align with the axis of the nuclear spiral as seen in Figure 2d. Previous explanations for the radio structure (Mundell et al 1995) invoked the standard unified AGN model to explain this emission as collimated outflow. However, there is an offset in orientation of the [OIII] ``cone" and the small-scale radio features. A projection effect would be possible, but this would necessitate that the NE side of the disc is closer to us than the SW side. This could only occur if the spiral arms were leading rather than trailing (Mundell et al 1995). Discussion - Fueling the Monster

Several possible scenerios emerge from these results. On the largest scales Gonzalez Delgado et al. (1997) noted that a large-scale bar appears to transport material towards an inner radius which corresponds to the calculated inner Linblad resonance (ILR) at roughly 7''. At this point, prominent dust and HII regions indicate substantial star formation. It is plausible that the apparent elongated region defined around the mini-spiral, and the small scale twisted feature, are in fact related to nested bar potentials, with the knotty structures representing starbursts formed by the shocked gas in the leading face of the bar. This would provide a straightforward explanation for transporting material down to the scales where viscous forces can take over (Sholsman et al. 1989), effectively fueling the active nucleus.

In the absense of any true bar potential, the fate of knots of star formation generated near the ILR will then be to drift inwards with time, being carried apart by differential rotation. This process could possibly mimic the loose spiral seen in the core region. In our own galaxy at roughly comparable scales, similar processes are thought to be at work (Morris et al. 1996). However, the Milky Way does not appear to have an active nucleus, and this in itself could not be an explanation for why some galaxy cores are fueled and some not.

Regan and Mulchaey (1998) claim to have found spiral dust lanes that appear to provide fuel for black holes at the centers of active galaxies, suggesting that that material does indeed spiral in towards the center, rather than being forced down in the presence of a strong bar potential. Our images would be consistent with this picture as the core elongated starburst region is seen as intersperced wispy spirals in the color maps of Figure 2. However, there is no theoretical or numerical model supporting such a scenerio, and it is not yet clear that such a mechanism could fuel the active nuclei.

Unified models and OASIS spectroscopy

Initial results from our OASIS data seem to be consistent with the unified model for NGC3227 proposed in (Delgado et al 1997, Arribas et al 1994), providing a higher resolution perspective on the HII region to the southwest, as well as the extended [OIII] and H$_\alpha$ to the northeast. The dusty region in the V-K color map falls over the blank region which separates the HII region from the core (Figure 3a), likely explaining the disconnected morphology. In the unified AGN picture, biconical emission line regions are thought to be the result of collimated continuum emission via a nuclear dust torus. Although with NGC3227 one would expect a counterpart to the extended [OIII] emission ``cone'' on the opposite side of the nucleus (SW), the dusty region would obscure such emission in addition to any H$_\alpha$ that extended from the nucleus to the separated HII region. There is however some evidence for smaller-scale conical morphology in our [NII]/H$_\alpha$ ratio map (Figure 3b), with [NII] being stronger along the axis defined by the [OIII] emission.


 
Figure 3:   Initial results from the OASIS data including (TOP) $H_\alpha$ map, (BOTTOM) [NII]/$H_\alpha$ ratio map
\begin{figure}
\centerline{
\psfig {figure=chapman_fig3.ps,height=6in}
} \end{figure}

However, if the extended [OIII] region to the northeast defines the collimation axis of a small-scale obscuring torus, then it is very difficult to interpret the radio feature as an outflow/jet since the two do not align. The major axis of the mini-spiral is well aligned with the radio feature, with the bright radio points apparently lying on the nucleus and one of the emission knots which is brighter at V-band than K. Our high resolution imaging along with OASIS IFU spectroscopy therefore suggest that the radio emission is unrelated to any kind of jet outflow, and instead is associated with the nuclear starburst. Also, Kotilainen et al. (1997) found a blue excess in their optical color maps lying in lobes on the NW-SE axis, roughly aligned with our spiral elongated feature, and consistent with our explanation.

On the other hand, if our observed small-scale elongation is some sort of twisted disk, its plane lies roughly perpendicular to the axis defined by the radio ``jet" observed at 6 and 18cm. For the radio emission to be interpreted as an outflow, the collimated [OIII] ionization picture would have to be abandoned. Given that the evidence for the single [OIII] extension taking on the shape of a cone is minimal, even with our improved resolution OASIS data, this scenerio is perhaps equally as plausible.


\begin{references}
% latex2html id marker 32
\reference{a93} Antonucci R., 1993,...
 ...o89} Shlosman I., Frank J., Begelman, M. C., 1989, \nat 338, 45
\end{references}


next up previous
Up: Home Page
Pierre Martin
10/22/1998